Response to lead blogger "Lucy"
In response to Lucy’s blog post, I think that she makes some very accurate points regarding the superiority theory and how it is portrayed on T.V. In her blog post she examines the popular show “The Office”. Even though I have not personally watched many episodes of The Office, I have actually viewed the scene that Lucy uses as her first example. While watching the scene I couldn't help but to hysterically laugh/ cry. This reiterated Lucy’s point about how “There is constant craziness happening in the office”. When looking at how the superiority theory relates to the show, she uses the character Michael Scott as a prime example. She talks about how Michael is always doing dumb things which are funny because we feel as if he should know better. If we were placed in the same situation as him we would have a completely different response/ reaction. An important point that I think Lucy makes is when say says, “The superiority theory may be seen as degrading towards people, but I feel that with T.V show characters this isn’t the case and sometimes makes us love the characters even more”. This statement is very true and not something I had thought about before. Typically we think of the superiority theory as being negative but I like how Lucy brought up the point that it doesn't always have to be this way when used in different contexts. Another important point that was discussed is how the show could potentially also relate to the relief theory. Jokes made in the show are often times “too controversial”. These jokes made in many situations bring up different emotions and cause laughter to arise as a form of relief.
I suppose I think of superiority as laughing at people, but perhaps that's not how it works. Perhaps it's more about just seeing someone as harmless and almost childlike, the way that we laugh at children.
ReplyDeleteI like the point you make about controversial jokes... Sometimes, they're even funnier as a result of how controversial and shocking they are, because we then laugh to relieve tension. I don't find The Office's jokes offensive because I know they are just characters that are intended to be funny because of how inappropriate they are, but I can imagine that it wouldn't be funny at all to work daily in an office where the boss jokingly makes sexist and racists comments towards his employees. Based on this, I think the assertion that our interpretation relies heavily on our personal situation in relation to a controversial joke is completely accurate.
ReplyDeleteThat's a good point in that we are laughing more at the inappropriateness in the case of Scott, whereas in other cases were are perhaps meant to be laughing more at the harm or hurt it causes.
Delete